Skip to content
Menu

Compare MDR and Managed SOC for Your MSP

What managed detection and response does, when an MSP needs it, what to look for and what to ask before you sign.

Build Your Shortlist

Sponsored positions appear first and are labeled; other tools run A to Z. Order is not a ranking. Open a tool for its full listing and sources.

What to Look For

Must Have

  • Human Analysts Around the Clock
  • Agreed Response Actions
  • Endpoint Coverage
  • Identity and Cloud Coverage
  • Multi-Tenant Console
  • PSA Ticket Integration
  • Clear Escalation Path

Worth Having

  • Bring Your Own EDR
  • Threat Hunting
  • Client-Ready Incident Reports
  • Incident Response Hours Included
  • White-Label Reporting
  • Compliance Reporting
  • Phone Escalation
MDR and Managed SOC shortlist: vendor, first three published feature notes, deployment and reviews. Open a tool for its full listing.
ToolVendorPublished Feature NotesDeploymentReviewsOpen
Adlumin MDR/XDRN-ableCombines SIEM and user and entity behavior analytics in an XDR platform
Provides 24/7 monitoring by an MDR analyst team
Includes threat intelligence and incident investigation
Not stated
AgileBlueAgileBlueProvides SOC monitoring and security case management
Creates and updates Autotask tickets for security cases
Maps security case criticality to PSA priority
Not stated
Arctic Wolf Aurora / MDRArctic Wolf24/7 security monitoring and investigation
Threat detection across customer environments
Security operations analyst support
Not stated
Barracuda Managed XDRBarracudaNot statedCloud
Blackpoint CyberBlackpoint24/7 managed detection and response
Human-led threat investigation and response
AI-enhanced alerts and contextual intelligence
Not stated
CovalenceField EffectMonitors endpoint and cloud activity, with network monitoring in MDR Complete
Combines automated detection with a 24/7 security operations team
Blocks malicious activity and can isolate affected endpoints
Not stated
CrowdStrike Falcon CompleteCrowdStrikeNot statedNot stated
eSentire MDReSentireMulti-signal security monitoring
24/7 threat hunting
Analyst-led threat investigation
Not stated
Expel MDRExpelProvides 24/7 monitoring and response from human analysts
Correlates detections across endpoint, cloud, identity, Kubernetes, and SaaS tools
Uses Expel Workbench to ingest and investigate security events
Not stated
HuntressHuntressManaged endpoint detection and response
Managed identity threat detection for Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace
Microsoft 365 configuration hardening and policy drift remediation
Cloud
Kaseya MDRKaseya24/7 monitoring and human-led threat response
Endpoint, Microsoft 365 and firewall coverage
AI-assisted alert correlation and triage
Cloud
Rapid7 Managed Detection and ResponseRapid7Not statedNot stated
Red Canary MDRRed CanaryEndpoint, identity and cloud threat detection
Security telemetry analysis and threat hunting
Investigation timelines with incident context
Not stated
SOCSoterSOCSoterCentralizes visibility into security tools and reporting
Supports communication with SOC analysts about alerts
Configures security escalations linked with Autotask
Not stated
Sophos MDRSophos24/7 monitoring, investigation, and response
Proactive threat hunting
Integrations with Sophos and third-party security tools
Not stated
Vigilance MDRSentinelOneNot statedNot stated
Vijilan ThreatRespondVijilan SecurityManaged SOC monitoring and threat hunting across connected tools
Integrates with existing EDR and other security telemetry
Analyst-led investigation and threat containment
Not stated

What Managed Detection and Response Is

Written by MSP Outpost.

In Short

MDR and managed SOC services put a vendor's analysts to work watching your clients' endpoints, identity and cloud services around the clock, then investigating and responding when something looks wrong. You resell or bundle the service, so your clients get overnight cover without you hiring a night shift. It differs from a SIEM, which is software you run yourself, and from EDR alone, which raises alerts but needs someone to act on them.

What It Does

  • Round-the-clock watching. Analysts review alerts at night and at weekends, when your own team is off.
  • Triage. Sorts real threats from noise so your team sees a handful of cases, not a flood of alerts.
  • Response. Isolates a machine, disables an account or blocks an address, within limits you agree in advance.
  • Identity and cloud cover. Watches sign-ins, mailbox rules and cloud activity as well as endpoints.
  • Investigation. Explains what happened, what was touched and what to do next, in terms you can pass to the client.
  • Reporting. Gives you per-client summaries of what was seen and handled, ready for reviews and renewals.
  • Threat hunting. Some services also search for signs of an attacker who has not set off an alert.

When You Need One

Starting OutOne or two technicians

You cannot staff nights and weekends yourself, and this is the cheapest way to cover them. Pick a service that works with the endpoint tools you already run, so you are not redeploying everywhere.

GrowingThree to ten technicians

Clients now have cloud services, remote staff and insurance questionnaires that ask who watches for attacks. Choose a service that covers identity and email as well as endpoints, and agree which actions the analysts take alone.

EstablishedTen technicians and up

You may run some detection in house, but covering every night of the year is still the hard part. Decide clearly which alerts the vendor handles and which come back to you, and keep that split in writing.

How It Is Priced

Most vendors quote rather than publish a price. Services are usually priced per user or per endpoint each month, and some add a per-client minimum or a setup fee. Check whether incident response hours are included or billed on top, whether the price covers identity and cloud sources or only endpoints, and what the minimum term is.

Switching

Changing services usually means redeploying agents or reconnecting integrations at every client, and rebuilding the rules about who gets called and what the analysts may do alone. Case history and tuning rarely come with you, so ask what you can export. Settle the term and the notice period before you sign, since some contracts run for several years.

Questions to Ask a Vendor

  1. Which response actions will your analysts take without asking me, and which do they only recommend?
  2. Do I have to use your agent, or can you work with the endpoint tool I already run?
  3. Are the analysts watching my clients your own staff, or a subcontractor?
  4. How many cases per client per month should I expect to be handed to my team?
  5. What is included in the price, and at what point does incident response become billable?
  6. How do you reach me out of hours, and how quickly after you confirm a real threat?
  7. Which identity and cloud services do you watch, and are they in the base price?
  8. What reports can I give a client, and can I put my own name on them?

Welcome Back

Sign in to your MSP Outpost account.